Secrets, Signals, and Story Hooks: What NCIS Can Teach Us About Writing Suspense

Woman watching TV with remote in hand and eating popcorn from a bowlFor years, my writing mentor kept encouraging me to watch NCIS. He insisted it was some of the best writing in television. Ever.

It’s not that I didn’t believe him. It’s just that I never found the time to make it happen.

And then, I did. And got hooked.

There is something eminently satisfying about settling in with an episode of NCIS. The team dynamics, the steady cadence of investigation, the flashes of humor against a backdrop of life-and-death stakes. But for me, as a writer of mystery and suspense, watching NCIS is more than entertainment.

It’s a masterclass.

How do they do it?

I find myself analyzing how the writers weave together plot threads, layer in emotional stakes, and keep us on the edge of our seats—all while delivering a self-contained story in under an hour. And I’m amazed by what I’ve learned from the show.

So today, I’d like to take you behind the scenes—not of the Navy Yard, but of story construction. Let’s look at what NCIS can teach us about building suspense… and how those same techniques find their way into my own stories.

Red Herrings and Real Clues

One of the hallmarks of NCIS is the strategic placement of red herrings. We meet a character who seems suspicious—too smooth, too nervous, too eager to help. Our instincts tingle. But then a clue shifts the spotlight and we follow a new lead, only to be surprised later when the truth snaps into place.

Riley Forte series Books 1 & 2, Nocturne in Ashes & Staccato PassageThis sleight of hand is essential to good suspense fiction. In my Riley Forte novels, I aim to guide readers down twisting corridors of possibility, allowing them to question, doubt, and piece things together alongside the protagonist. The trick is to play fair—every answer must be supported by clues that were there all along, hidden in plain sight.

Character Conflict as a Pressure Cooker

Another tool NCIS wields well is interpersonal tension. Think of those simmering moments between Gibbs and Tony, or when Abby’s moral compass conflicts with procedural protocol. These emotional undercurrents heighten suspense because they make every decision weightier, every step more uncertain.

In my own writing, I strive to craft characters who care deeply—and differently. Conflict doesn’t always mean shouting; sometimes it’s the quiet resistance, the unspoken hesitation, the glance that says more than words. Suspense lives not only in what’s happening but in how it matters to the people involved.

Ticking Clocks and Narrative Clues

Ever noticed how many NCIS episodes hinge on a tight timeline? A suspect in custody for only 24 hours. A bomb set to detonate. A virus on the verge of release. These ticking clocks create urgency and focus, pulling us into the story’s momentum.

Volcano erupting fireI often use a similar device.

In Nocturne in Ashes, the eruption of Mt. Rainier sets the stage for a countdown no one can ignore. Time becomes a character—unforgiving, unrelenting. When used well, it forces action and sharpens suspense like a blade.

Signals from the Writers’ Room

One of the most fascinating things about NCIS is how the show signals what’s important without tipping its hand. A camera lingers a second too long. A line of dialogue gets echoed later in the episode. As viewers, we learn to pay attention—even when we don’t know why.

As a writer, I love embedding subtle signals—echoes of phrases, symbolic imagery, character callbacks. They create that satisfying “aha!” moment when everything clicks into place. It’s like leaving a trail of breadcrumbs through the forest of fiction.

Suspense That Satisfies

Ultimately, NCIS works because it marries plot with emotion. We’re not just curious about the crime—we care about the people solving it.

Woman sitting on the curb, absorbed in reading Staccato Passage, by Joslyn ChaseWe want justice, yes, but we also want connection, redemption, closure. That’s what makes suspense truly satisfying.

And that’s what I aim for in my stories. Whether it’s a cold case cracking open after decades, or a musician-turned-operative racing against time, I want my readers to feel swept into a puzzle that matters. To engage both heart and mind.

How about you? Do you watch shows like NCIS with a writer’s eye—or simply for the thrill of it? Have you spotted techniques that kept you hooked? I’d love to hear your take in the comments.

Let’s keep learning from the stories around us—and weaving their wisdom into our own.


4 Responses to “Secrets, Signals, and Story Hooks: What NCIS Can Teach Us About Writing Suspense”

  1. I’m not a huge fan of NCIS, because the Gibbs character grates on my nerves. He’s the sort of bloke I’d be tempted to give a good slapping to. LOL.
    Having said that, I totally agree with you on how the writers weave clues and red herrings into the show. I always try to do similar stuff in my own work and I do watch the show and many like it for that reason.

    • JoslynChase says:

      Hi Thomas, thanks so much for reading and taking the time to share your thoughts. I get what you’re saying with Gibbs, but I still find him somewhat endearing despite his irritating manner 🙂 I have become a huge fan of the show. Best wishes to you in your own work and thanks again for stopping by to read my post.

  2. Pat Geesin says:

    I responded to your email but one thing I forgot to mention. I’ve also been a viewer of the numerous NCIS spinoffs. Some I liked more than others, (like NCIS LA my favorite of those) but the talented writers still abound!

    • JoslynChase says:

      I haven’t yet had the chance to try out any of the spinoffs, but when I do, I’ll start with LA since it found favor with you. I also plan to watch Tony and Ziva and see how that goes at some point. Thanks for reading and commenting!

Leave a Reply